! Advertisements ! ⁈

These sections are reserved for advertisements. While our in-house advertising system is under development, Third party Ad-sense will be displayed here. For more information, please refer to our “Advertisements” insight.

Go to Index or search here


Bank Guarantees and Performance Security: How Medium MSMEs Must Record, Track, and Account for Guarantee Obligations

⬟ Intro :

A medium MSME civil contractor in Nagpur, Maharashtra had three government contracts each requiring a performance bank guarantee. Total BG exposure: Rs. 34.8 lakh. Cash margin deposited with the bank: Rs. 10.44 lakh. The accountant recorded the cash margin as a current asset and the commission as a bank charge. The BG obligations were not disclosed as contingent liabilities anywhere. One contract had a performance dispute. The government client invoked the guarantee: Rs. 11.6 lakh. The bank paid the client and debited the contractor. The cash margin of Rs. 3.48 lakh was appropriated. The remaining Rs. 8.12 lakh hit the current account directly. No provision existed. The Rs. 8.12 lakh was an unexpected cash shock. The statutory audit then flagged the undisclosed Rs. 34.8 lakh of BG exposure as a qualification: it should have appeared as contingent liability for two years. It had not.

A bank guarantee is not a loan, not an expense, and not a simple transaction. It is a contingent liability: an obligation that may or may not require payment depending on whether the guarantee is invoked. Most MSME accounts record only the cash margin and commission, while omitting the guarantee obligation from contingent liability disclosure. When the guarantee is invoked, the cash shock is sudden and unprovisioned. When auditors review, undisclosed BGs become qualifications. Three distinct elements need correct treatment: the cash margin (an asset), the commission (an expense), and the contingent liability (a disclosure, not a balance sheet item, until invocation).

This article covers the types of bank guarantees used by MSMEs, the correct accounting for each element, contingent liability disclosure, what entries to make when a BG is invoked, and how to track BG expiry to recover margin money.

⬟ What a Bank Guarantee Is and the Three Financial Elements It Creates :

A bank guarantee (BG) is a commitment by a bank to pay a specified amount to a beneficiary if the MSME fails to meet a defined obligation. Payment is typically unconditional on demand. Three common types for MSMEs. Performance bank guarantee (PBG): guarantees completion of contracted work to specified quality. Typically 5% to 10% of contract value. Released on satisfactory completion. Earnest money deposit guarantee (EMD BG): replaces cash EMD for tender participation. Prevents the MSME from locking cash in multiple tender deposits. Released if not won or replaced by PBG on award. Financial bank guarantee: guarantees a specific payment obligation such as advance repayment, deferred customs duty, or lease security. Released when the payment obligation is fulfilled. Each BG creates three financial elements: the cash margin (deposited with the bank as security, a current asset), the commission and charges (the cost of the BG facility, an expense), and the contingent liability (the full face value, disclosed in notes to accounts until invocation).

A medium MSME construction company in Ahmedabad, Gujarat wins a municipal contract worth Rs. 60 lakh. The contract requires a PBG of 10%: Rs. 6 lakh. Bank terms for the Rs. 6 lakh PBG: cash margin 25% = Rs. 1.5 lakh as fixed deposit; balance secured by property; commission 1.5% per annum = Rs. 9,000/year; BG validity 18 months. Accounting entries at BG issuance: BG Margin FD (asset) Dr Rs. 1,50,000 / Bank current account Cr Rs. 1,50,000 BG Commission expense Dr Rs. 9,000 / Bank current account Cr Rs. 9,000 Contingent liability note in financial statements: "Bank guarantees outstanding as on 31 March 20XX: Rs. 6,00,000 in favour of Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation for contract reference [X]. Secured by fixed deposit of Rs. 1,50,000 and property mortgage." This note discloses the exposure without a balance sheet entry, because payment is not probable unless the BG is invoked.

⬟ Why Incorrect BG Accounting Creates Financial and Audit Risks for Medium MSMEs :

Correct BG accounting produces three direct benefits. The first is accurate financial statements. When contingent liabilities are disclosed, lenders and clients see the business's complete financial exposure. A business with Rs. 50 lakh of outstanding BGs has a different risk profile than one with zero, even if both show the same balance sheet. The disclosure makes this visible. The second is audit compliance. Undisclosed contingent liabilities including BGs are among the most common causes of audit qualifications in medium MSME accounts. A qualification on financial statements submitted for a bank loan or tender review damages credibility. Correct disclosure eliminates this risk. The third is margin money protection. Systematic BG tracking ensures margin money is recovered promptly when a BG is released, rather than lying with the bank past the expiry date or being silently retained.

A medium MSME mechanical contractor in Chennai, Tamil Nadu maintained a BG register listing each BG with its expiry date and margin fixed deposit reference. When a BG was due to expire, the accountant contacted the client 30 days before to request either a release letter or a BG extension. Over three years, this system ensured Rs. 8.4 lakh of margin money was recovered promptly rather than lying unclaimed with the bank. A medium MSME IT services company in Pune, Maharashtra issued two advance payment guarantees totalling Rs. 22 lakh. The accountant recorded both as contingent liabilities in the notes to accounts, disclosed the Rs. 5.5 lakh margin fixed deposits as current assets, and recorded the annual commission of Rs. 33,000 as bank charges. When the bank reviewed the company's working capital renewal, the credit officer noted the clean BG disclosure and commented it gave a clear picture of the company's commitment obligations.

For medium MSME owners growing through government and institutional contracts, bank guarantees are a routine tool. The BG obligation, the margin money locked up with the bank, and the risk of invocation are all real financial exposures that the business carries for the duration of active contracts. The accountant who understands and correctly records these obligations gives the management accurate financial visibility. The CA who reviews the accounts and ensures complete contingent liability disclosure protects the business from audit qualifications. The owner who tracks BG expiry dates protects the cash that is otherwise silently retained by the bank.

⬟ How BG Accounting Is Currently Handled in Medium MSMEs :

In practice, most medium MSME accounts record the cash margin as a fixed deposit (correctly) and the commission as a bank charge (correctly), but omit the contingent liability disclosure in the notes to accounts (incorrectly). This is common because: the BG obligation does not require a balance sheet entry, the accountant is often unaware of the disclosure requirement, and the BG register is not maintained systematically. Under AS 29 (Ind AS 37 for applicable entities), contingent liabilities must be disclosed if the possibility of an outflow is not remote. An outstanding bank guarantee within its validity period is a contingent liability that must be disclosed.

⬟ How Digital Banking and ERP Integration Are Changing BG Management :

Banks are increasingly offering digital BG issuance and tracking through corporate banking portals. A medium MSME can view all outstanding BGs, validity dates, and margin details on a single screen, reducing the risk of unnoticed expiries. NFRA and ICAI have been progressively tightening contingent liability disclosure standards. Future auditing guidance is likely to require more specific BG disclosures: contract nature, invocation probability assessment, and any provisions made. Medium MSMEs that already disclose BGs correctly will have no adjustment to make.

⬟ The Complete Accounting Treatment for Bank Guarantees at Each Stage :

Complete accounting treatment across the BG lifecycle. BG issuance: cash margin transferred to BG margin fixed deposit account (current asset). Commission recorded as BG commission expense. Contingent liability note added to financial statements showing BG face value, beneficiary, and security. Subsequent periods: annual commission recorded as expense in the year incurred. Contingent liability note updated at each balance sheet date. Margin FD classified as current asset (if BG expires within 12 months) or non-current asset (if validity exceeds 12 months from balance sheet date). BG release: margin FD refunded to bank current account. Any interest earned on the margin FD recognised as interest income. Contingent liability note updated to remove the released BG. BG invocation: bank pays the beneficiary and debits the MSME's account. Cash margin appropriated by the bank is set off. Any amount beyond the cash margin becomes a bank liability (overdraft or demand loan). Full invoked amount recorded as a loss (debit: BG invocation loss; credit: bank account or bank liability). Contingent liability note updated to remove the invoked BG.

● Step-by-Step Process

Maintain a BG register: one row per BG, capturing BG number, bank, beneficiary, contract reference, face value, BG type, issue date, expiry date, cash margin amount, margin FD account number, annual commission, and current status. At BG issuance: make two entries in Tally. First, move the cash margin to a dedicated BG margin FD ledger (not mixed with general fixed deposits). Second, record the commission as BG commission expense. Monthly: check the register for BGs expiring in the next 60 days. If release is due, request the release letter from the client. If extension is needed, submit the bank extension request at least 15 working days before expiry. At financial year-end: prepare the contingent liability note listing every outstanding BG with beneficiary, face value, nature, and security. Share this list with the CA for inclusion in the annual financial statements. On BG invocation: record immediately with full entries. Inform the CA. The invocation loss must appear in the accounts for the period in which it occurs, not the period in which it is discovered.

● Tools & Resources

Tally Prime: create a dedicated ledger called BG Margin Fixed Deposits under current assets (or non-current assets if long-term). Create a BG Commission expense ledger under bank charges. Use the memo voucher for the contingent liability note to keep track without affecting balance sheet totals. A BG register spreadsheet with a colour-coded expiry status column (green = 60 days away, yellow = 30 days, red = 15 days) is the simplest and most practical expiry tracking tool.

● Common Mistakes

Recording BG margin fixed deposits under general fixed deposits rather than a separate ledger is the most common tracking error. When margin money is mixed with general FDs, it becomes invisible. The accountant cannot identify release-dependent deposits from free ones, leading to delayed recovery and, in some cases, the bank retaining margin past expiry unnoticed. Omitting the contingent liability disclosure is the most significant accounting error. Outstanding BGs must be disclosed under AS 29 (Ind AS 37 for applicable entities). Auditors who find undisclosed BG obligations issue qualifications, damaging the statements' credibility for bank, tender, and compliance purposes. Recording a BG invocation as just a bank debit is the third error. Invocation is a loss event requiring entries at the correct gross amount, with margin appropriation and bank debit tracked separately. The full picture must be visible: total loss, margin coverage, and any resulting bank liability.

● Challenges and Limitations

Managing multiple concurrent BGs across several contracts is operationally complex. A contractor with 8 to 10 active projects may have BGs at various stages simultaneously. Maintaining the BG register with monthly discipline during busy periods requires treating it as a fixed monthly task. The cash margin locked in BGs is a growing working capital constraint. A business with Rs. 80 lakh of outstanding BGs at 25% cash margin has Rs. 20 lakh of working capital locked up. Planning for this as part of the annual working capital assessment, and factoring margin requirements into the cost of each new contract bid, is a treasury discipline that medium MSMEs often do not formalise until the constraint becomes acute.

● Examples & Scenarios

A medium MSME fabrication contractor in Surat, Gujarat had six BGs outstanding with a total face value of Rs. 42 lakh. The CA found none had been disclosed as contingent liabilities for two years. Margin money (Rs. 12.6 lakh across six FDs) was correctly recorded, but the guarantee obligations were absent. The bank had requested audited statements for working capital renewal. The CA required the disclosures before signing. The bank's credit officer specifically asked about invocation probability: the clean project track record supported a low-probability assessment and the facility was renewed. A medium MSME facility services company in Delhi had a BG expiry failure. A Rs. 5.2 lakh PBG expired September 30 without a release letter being submitted. The client had confirmed satisfactory performance but no formal release was filed. The bank retained Rs. 1.56 lakh cash margin. The accountant discovered this in January year-end review. The bank declined to refund the margin on an expired BG. The Rs. 1.56 lakh was written off. A 30-day pre-expiry calendar reminder would have prevented this loss entirely.

● Best Practices

Update the BG register on the day each BG event occurs: issuance, extension, release, or invocation. A register updated only quarterly or at year-end is not useful for expiry tracking. The update takes five minutes per event and prevents margin losses from lapsed guarantees. Set calendar reminders at 60 days and 30 days before each expiry. At 60 days: assess project status. At 30 days: send the release request or the bank extension request. Banks require at least 15 working days for extensions: a 30-day reminder ensures adequate lead time. Share the BG register with the CA quarterly. The CA needs it to prepare the contingent liability note and to verify the margin FD balances match the accounts. An annual share only at year-end is insufficient for businesses with active BG movement during the year.

⬟ Disclaimer :

This content is intended for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute professional accounting, legal, or banking advisory. The accounting treatments, disclosure requirements, and journal entries described are based on general principles under Indian accounting standards (AS 29 and Ind AS 37) and commonly observed practice. The specific accounting treatment for bank guarantees may vary depending on the applicable financial reporting framework, the terms of the guarantee, and the business's specific circumstances. Medium MSME owners and their accountants should consult a qualified chartered accountant for guidance on the specific BG accounting treatment applicable to their entity and transactions.


⬟ How Desi Ustad Can Help You :

This week, ask the accountant one question: how many bank guarantees does the business currently have outstanding? Get the answer in writing as a list with each BG's face value, beneficiary, and expiry date. Then check: are all of these disclosed as contingent liabilities in the most recent audited financial statements? If the answer is no (or if the list cannot be produced quickly), the BG tracking system needs to be set up. Share the list with the CA and ask for a contingent liability note to be prepared for the next set of financial statements. This one action improves both the accuracy of the financial statements and the protection of the margin money locked in those guarantees.

Register your business with our online directory or join our bidding platform.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1: What is a contingent liability and why must bank guarantees be disclosed as one?

A1: The disclosure requirement exists because financial statements must give a complete picture of all obligations that may affect the business's financial position. A business with Rs. 50 lakh of outstanding bank guarantees has a materially different risk profile than one with none, even if both have identical balance sheets. The BG disclosure allows readers of the financial statements (lenders, investors, potential clients, and the management itself) to assess the additional risk that the contingent exposure represents. The disclosure does not bring the BG obligation onto the balance sheet as a liability because payment is not

Q2: How should the BG margin fixed deposit be classified in the balance sheet?

A2: The correct classification of the margin FD also matters for financial ratio analysis. Current assets that are locked as BG margins are not freely available working capital: they cannot be withdrawn without the bank's consent during the BG validity period. When calculating the quick ratio or assessing the available liquidity of the business, BG margin deposits should be mentally excluded from the free current assets. A business that appears to have Rs. 15 lakh in current fixed deposits but Rs. 12 lakh of that is locked as BG margins has only Rs. 3 lakh of

Q3: What journal entries are needed when a bank guarantee is invoked?

A3: The gross recording of the BG invocation is important for two reasons. First, it provides management visibility of the full economic loss from the invocation, not just the net cash impact after the margin offset. If the BG was Rs. 10 lakh and the margin was Rs. 2.5 lakh, the loss is Rs. 10 lakh (the full invocation amount), of which Rs. 2.5 lakh was covered by the margin already with the bank and Rs. 7.5 lakh was a new cash outflow. Recording only Rs. 7.5 lakh understates the impact of the margin money that

Q4: What is a counter-guarantee and when does it apply to MSME BG accounting?

A4: The counter-guarantee disclosure in financial statements should describe both the original BG and the counter-guarantee: the original BG is disclosed as a contingent liability at its face value, and the counter-guarantee is disclosed as a contingent asset (a possible inflow if the counter-guarantee is called). Under Ind AS 37, contingent assets are disclosed in notes but not recognised in the balance sheet unless the inflow is virtually certain. The net exposure (after the counter-guarantee protection) can be mentioned in the notes as additional context. For an MSME that is the counter-guarantor rather than the beneficiary

Q5: How does a bank decide how much cash margin to require for a bank guarantee?

A5: The cash margin requirement has a direct working capital impact that the MSME must plan for when bidding on contracts that require BGs. Before submitting a tender that will require a PBG of 10% of contract value, the MSME should calculate: the BG face value (10% of contract value), the cash margin required (for example, 25% of BG value), and the working capital to be locked up for the duration of the contract. For a Rs. 50 lakh contract with a 10% PBG and 25% cash margin, the working capital locked is Rs. 50L x

Q6: What happens to BG margin money if the MSME's bank account is frozen or the business closes?

A6: For an MSME going through financial distress (approaching NPA classification or negotiating restructuring), the outstanding BG portfolio creates an additional complexity. The bank holding the BGs may be both the lender (for the working capital or term loan that is being restructured) and the BG issuing bank. In a restructuring, the bank will typically not release BG margin FDs until both the BG obligations and the restructured loan obligations are addressed. The MSME in distress must disclose all BG obligations to the restructuring advisor and the bank's credit committee as part of the total exposure

Q7: How is BG commission treated for income tax purposes?

A7: In addition to the commission, the stamp duty paid on the BG and any processing fees charged by the bank at BG issuance are also deductible business expenses. If the BG is invoked and the MSME incurs a loss (the full invocation amount), the loss is typically deductible under Section 37(1) as a business loss arising in the course of carrying on business, provided the BG was issued for a legitimate business purpose. The key condition for deductibility of the invocation loss is that it arose in the normal course of carrying on the business,

Q8: Can a bank guarantee be cancelled before its expiry date?

A8: The process for obtaining a BG release letter varies by the type of beneficiary. For government clients (PWD, CPWD, municipal bodies), the release process involves submitting a completion certificate or a project closure report to the relevant department, which then issues the release letter through its internal administrative process. This process can take two to eight weeks depending on the department and the project. For private corporate clients, the process is faster: typically one to two weeks after satisfactory project completion and acceptance. The MSME should initiate the release process as soon as the underlying

Q9: What is the difference between a performance bank guarantee and an advance payment guarantee?

A9: In the MSME's accounts, both PBG and APG are recorded in the same way: cash margin as an asset, commission as an expense, and the full face value as a contingent liability disclosure. However, there is an important difference in how the underlying transaction is recorded. When the client pays an advance to the MSME (covered by an APG), the advance received is a liability in the MSME's books (credit to advance from clients or deferred revenue) until the services are delivered. As the MSME delivers services, the advance is progressively recognised as revenue. The

Q10: How should an MSME account for a bank guarantee issued on behalf of a subsidiary or related party?

A10: The risk in guaranteeing a related party's BG is that the MSME assumes the contingent liability without direct involvement in the underlying contract performance. If the related party fails to perform and the guarantee is invoked, the MSME bears the financial loss without having controlled the project or relationship that led to the invocation. For this reason, issuing bank guarantees on behalf of related parties should be done with explicit management approval (board resolution for companies) and with a clear understanding of the related party's financial capacity to reimburse the MSME if the guarantee is
Please submit any questions via the 'suggestions' window. We are committed to enhancing the user experience by remaining fair, transparent, and user-friendly.



! Advertisements !
! Advertisements ! ⁈

These sections are reserved for advertisements. While our in-house advertising system is under development, Third party Ad-sense will be displayed here. For more information, please refer to our “Advertisements” insight.